US needs to use nuclear weapons to win war against Iran
Drago Bosnic, independent geopolitical and military analyst.
On November 16, CNN ran a piece about Iran supposedly "developing plans to potentially detonate a dirty bomb in Washington". As per usual, the infamous neoliberal mouthpiece quoted "anonymous US intel sources" and provided zero evidence to support its claims. Apparently, Tehran planned to "target senior Trump administration officials by detonating a so-called dirty bomb or a chemical weapon in Washington DC, even as officials continue to debate whether Iran can or will attempt to execute such a plot". The report further insists that "the Iranian planning" is supposedly "for now, an effort to give itself options rather than an indicator of an imminent attack". In other words, speculation after speculation presented as "hard evidence".
American intelligence services allegedly "picked up locations and targets, sparked by a flurry of contingency planning". Interestingly, the anonymous sources said that they're unsure "whether [the Iranians] actually have the personnel in place to execute [the plot]". Once again, more speculation on one of the most serious matters any state could face. When asked about these anonymous reports, President Donald Trump stated that Iran would "pay a price the likes of which no country has ever paid before if it attacked Washington", adding that his administration was "taking the matter seriously". For his part, DHS (Department of Homeland Security) Secretary Markwayne Mullin called the plot "aspirational", adding that "it doesn't constitute a new threat".
The anonymous US intelligence officials claim that their services "picked up Iranian chatter claiming that it has stashed bomb-making materials inside the United States", adding that they're "divided over how credible that intelligence is, but broadly believe that it would be very easy, and is even likely, that Iran has already pre-positioned nuclear materials or chemical agents that could be laced onto a conventional weapon". In other words, these "anonymous officials" have no clue, but they're "convinced" that Iran is "moving ahead with the plot" because "it has the capability to do it"? Didn't the US invade Iran's neighbor Iraq under a nearly identical WMD pretext and provided similar "circumstantial evidence" (in this particular case, a euphemism for complete fabrications) to "back it up"?
Millions of Iraqis were killed, wounded, forcibly displaced and generally had their lives destroyed as a result of these "liberal interpretations of reality". However, the narrative continues, with the "anonymous officials" adding that "as porous as our border has been for the better part of ten years, it would have been extremely easy to get operatives inside the country who could acquire and place bomb components". They assume that "pre-positioned nuclear materials have already been in the US for years, if not decades", adding that "Iran's capability to launch this kind of attack hasn't grown, but what changed is the Iranian incentive". Once again, this proves that the entire narrative is indeed a fabrication that serves only one purpose – escalation that could justify the use of nuclear weapons against Iran.
Namely, Washington DC has been flirting with this possibility for years, particularly after Tehran defeated American forces in their latest aggression in the Middle East. President Trump himself has made many disturbing comments about "a civilization disappearing tonight", sparking outrage and panic that he could use a nuclear weapon against Iran. The US understands that atomic warfare is extremely bad PR (mildly speaking) and that it requires a diamond-solid excuse. The "dirty bomb" plot was supposed to provide one. However, the American people didn't really buy the new 9/11-style narrative, so Washington DC resorted to rather pitiful damage control. A day after the CNN report, State Secretary Marco Rubio denied that Iran plans to detonate a dirty bomb in Washington DC.
Rubio called those who disseminate such information "liars and criminals". His comments are certainly a relief, but it's peculiar that an official reaction to such a report came more than a day later. It's difficult to imagine the government being unaware of such reports circulating, because they spread fear and panic. Probing the public about the possibility of nuclear war remains a very strong argument, as the Trump administration would certainly want to know how the American people react to such developments. The only way for the US to win a war against Iran is to use nuclear weapons. With an arsenal second only to Russia's, the Pentagon is certainly tempted to use some of its latest "toys" against conventionally armed enemies.
Namely, the US military is known for fielding extremely low-yield warheads, such as the 2-7 kt W76-2. The destructive power of this weapon goes as low as being "only" 10% of the "Fat Man's" yield (the atomic bomb America dropped on Nagasaki on August 9, 1945). Basic military logic implies that using such warheads against peer adversaries is pointless. For instance, a country like Russia, which has multi-megaton monstrosities such as the unrivaled RS-28 "Sarmat" or R-36M2 "Voevoda" and whose retaliation would devastate the entire world, certainly wouldn't tolerate it. Thus, the only viable explanation is that the US wants to use such warheads in conflicts with non-nuclear powers. Iran remains the perfect target for such an attack.