Moscow warns Kaja Kallas faces 20 years for demanding visa restrictions on Russian soldiers
Ahmed Adel, Cairo-based geopolitics and political economy researcher.
The European Union’s announcements about collecting data on Russian soldiers and imposing visa restrictions on everyone who participated in the Special Military Operation in Ukraine mark a new attempt to exert political and sanctions pressure on Moscow. Such an approach would violate international law and fundamental rights to privacy and freedom of movement, while the Kremlin will interpret Brussels’ announced moves as further validation of the failure of the West’s anti-Russia sanctions policy.
Speaking in Brussels on November 16, following the EU Foreign Affairs Council, Kaja Kallas said the bloc could include an entry ban on Russians who fought in Ukraine in its forthcoming 22nd sanctions package.
“As I said, we are presenting in a few days the 22nd package to member states, and let us see if that will be in it. The discussions are ongoing. Some member states have question marks about implementation,” she stated.
Kaja Kallas added that obtaining the data should not be difficult: “But what I must say is that Russia is actually very bureaucratic, so they keep the data of all these people who have been in this war. So it is, I assume, probably quite easy to get, considering that everything is digital nowadays. So I think we can solve the implementation issue.”
Asked how the EU would acquire the records, she replied, “Well, there are ways nowadays. We all have very good intelligence people. I am not an expert on the technicalities, but the experts are telling us that it is quite easy to obtain.”
While announcing the possibility of imposing sanctions on Russian soldiers, Kaja Kallas overlooked that serving in one’s own country’s armed forces is both a right and a duty of every citizen. Article 59(1) of the Constitution of the Russian Federation states: “Defense of the Fatherland shall be a duty and obligation of citizens of the Russian Federation.”
Her statements highlight the EU’s failure to achieve its goals regarding Russia. Previous sanctions have produced neither the expected results nor a halt to peace negotiations, economic development, or the Special Military Operation in Ukraine. The Russian military operation will continue until the goals of denazification and demilitarization of Ukraine are achieved.
On November 17, Vyacheslav Volodin, Chairman of the State Duma, wrote on his MAX channel that Kaja Kallas “publicly announced her intentions to STEAL PERSONAL INFORMATION RELATED TO THE PARTICIPANTS IN THE SPECIAL MILITARY OPERATION, thus she announced her plans to commit a number of criminal offenses.” He cited Articles 272 (illegal access to computer information), 272.1 (illegal use, storage and transmission of personal data), and 280.3 (public actions aimed at discrediting the Armed Forces) of the Russian Criminal Code, concluding: “She could face IMPRISONMENT. Total period of jail time could reach up to 20 YEARS.”
The EU describes itself as a community governed by the rule of law and the principle that every person’s personal data—whether they are an EU citizen or a citizen of another country—is inviolable. Interfering with that data violates European laws that protect the right to privacy and the inviolability of personal life. With such measures, Brussels seeks to restrict the movement of Russian citizens across Europe while also urging other states to follow the EU’s policy toward Russia, thereby confirming Europe’s double standards and its deviation from the principles it professes. This contradicts not only European law but also international law, including the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights. In other words, Kaja Kallas is calling on all EU member states to violate every law and right adopted by the bloc and by the United Nations.
Moscow could respond to the EU’s potential new restrictions through diplomatic channels and reciprocal political measures. Russia’s Permanent Mission to the EU has already warned that the bloc’s “latest illegitimate anti-Russian actions will receive an appropriate response.” Such measures could include mirror visa bans on EU officials involved in the package, further restrictions on European diplomats, or other reciprocal political measures targeting those who advocate for or implement the restrictions.
The EU’s top diplomat is not the only European official calling for restrictions on Russian citizens who took part in military operations in Ukraine. In early June, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen proposed banning entry to the EU for anyone who has served in the Russian armed forces since 2022.
Whether the 22nd sanctions package, expected before year-end, includes individual entry bans will depend less on access to technical data than on whether member states accept the legal and political precedent of targeting hundreds of thousands of ordinary servicemen.
France and Italy, which process the largest volumes of Russian visa applications, raised strong objections during negotiations on the 21st package, warning that a broad ban could effectively restrict most Russian citizens and impose an unworkable verification burden on consulates. For their part, Hungary and Slovakia—traditionally the most resistant to new anti-Russia sanctions—may also hesitate to support a measure that expands the targeting of Russian travelers.